Which is Better for Countertops: Quartz, Granite or Marble


Choosing the right countertop material for your kitchen or bathroom remodel can be a daunting task. The three most popular options on the market today are quartz, granite, and marble. Each material has its own unique properties and considerations when it comes to cost, durability, maintenance, and aesthetics. Knowing the key differences between quartz vs granite vs marble will help you select the best surface for your needs and lifestyle.

In this comprehensive guide, we will compare and contrast quartz, granite, and marble countertops to help you make an informed decision for your next remodeling project.

Durability and Strength

Quartz is one of the most durable countertop materials available. It is composed of ground natural quartz crystals combined with polymer resins for binding. This engineered stone is highly resistant to scratches, stains, heat, and daily wear and tear. Quartz rates 7-8 on the Mohs hardness scale, compared to diamonds which rate 10. With proper sealing, quartz countertops can last a lifetime.

Granite is a completely natural stone that originates from quarries. It ranks 6-7 on the hardness scale, slightly softer than quartz. Granite is still an extremely durable surface that can last for decades with proper sealing and care. Minor scratches and chips can occur over time.

Marble is a metamorphic limestone with a hardness rating of only 3-4 on the Mohs scale. It is much softer compared to quartz and granite, making it prone to etching, scratching, and staining. Marble requires vigilant maintenance and sealing to prevent damage. It offers elegance but is less ideal for heavy usage areas.

Durability Winner: Quartz

With its superior hardness and scratch-resistance, quartz is the most durable option for busy kitchens and bathrooms. Granite follows as a close second best. Marble offers beauty but requires more maintenance.

Appearance and Styles

Quartz patterns are engineered for consistency. Popular styles mimic natural stone but lack veins or movement. The uniformity creates a clean, modern look. Quartz comes in a wide array of colors from neutrals to bold hues. Finishes can be matte to glossy.

Granite boasts unique natural patterns with distinctive veining, flecks, and movement. No two granite slabs are exactly alike. Colors range from light granites like white fantasy to darker options like black pearl. Granite offers an elegant and timeless look.

Marble is prized for its graceful, fluid veining and upscale aesthetic. It comes in a diverse spectrum of colors and patterns. Marble countertops create a refined, Old World charm. However, the soft stone develops a patina with use.

Appearance Winner: Personal Preference

Beauty is subjective. Those wanting modern and consistent will prefer quartz. For natural uniqueness, granite and marble offer alluring options. Marble will show wear over time.

Cost and Value Comparison

Quartz lands in the middle price-wise, costing $40-100 per square foot installed. The durability and low maintenance make quartz a valuable long-term investment. Higher-end designer brands can cost over $100 per square foot.

Granite has a similar installed price range of $40-100 per square foot on average. Exotic granites can be pricier. This natural stone adds resale value for years to come with proper upkeep.

Marble is the most expensive option, costing $70-250 per square foot installed. The huge price range depends on marble variety and color patterns. Frequent sealing and maintenance are required.

Cost Winner: Mid-range Granite or Quartz

For best value, durability, and cost, a mid-grade granite or quartz offers the top bang for your buck. High-end marble costs a premium while showing wear sooner.

Maintenance Requirements

Quartz is almost maintenance-free, only needing occasional cleaning with soap and water. It never needs sealing or polishing. The non-porous surface resists most stains and etching. Minimal care is a perk.

Granite needs to be sealed every 1-2 years to prevent stains and bacteria buildup. Annual polishing is also advised to keep granite looking its best. Avoid abrasive cleaners which can dull the surface.

Marble is high-maintenance, needing frequent sealing 3-4 times per year. Harsh cleaners and acids can damage the delicate stone. Keeping marble pristine requires dedication.

Maintenance Winner: Quartz

With simple cleaning the only requirement, quartz clearly wins when it comes to easy care. Granite needs some upkeep, while marble requires major commitment.

Which is Better for Countertops: The Verdict

For most homeowners, quartz is the best all-around countertop material due to its optimal balance of durability, maintenance, cost, and style. Durable granite follows closely as a second choice. Elegant marble offers unmatched beauty for those dedicated to meticulous care.

Consider your budget, design priorities, and maintenance tolerance. For busy kitchens prone to spills and stains, durable quartz or granite are ideal options. If seeking a refined look with classic character, marble brings unique charm despite higher care. Discuss your needs with a kitchen designer to select the perfect countertop for your home.

With this helpful comparison of key qualities, you can now decide which material is the best fit for your countertops – quartz, granite, or marble. All three natural stone options add beauty and value to any remodeling project. The right choice comes down to aligning your needs with the advantages of each surface. Use these insights to make an informed, confident decision on your new countertops.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is most expensive, quartz, granite or marble?

Marble is generally the most expensive of the three options, starting around $70 per square foot installed. Granite and quartz are typically in a similar mid-range price point of $40-100 per square foot installed. High-end designer quartz or exotic granite can cost over $100 per square foot.

Is quartz more durable than granite?

Quartz is slightly more durable than granite due to its higher rating on the Mohs hardness scale. Both offer long-lasting performance, but quartz is practically indestructible under normal kitchen use. Granite can develop minor scratches or chips over many years.

Does marble stain easily?

Yes, marble stains easily compared to granite and quartz. The porous, softer surface absorbs liquids, grease, and acidic substances. Frequent sealing is required to protect marble countertops and maintain their flawless appearance.

What are the disadvantages of quartz?

Quartz has very few drawbacks, but the engineered material lacks the natural uniqueness of genuine stone. The uniform patterns may be viewed as too consistent. Whites and grays can appear slightly artificial at times.

Does quartz hold its value?

Quartz offers excellent resale value, nearly comparable to natural granite. As one of the most durable and low-maintenance options, quartz countertops retain their beauty and function for years, appealing to potential home buyers.

Final Thoughts on Choosing Countertops

When selecting quartz, granite, or marble surfaces, consider your budget, kitchen design style, and maintenance tolerance. For beautiful high-end marble, be prepared for meticulous care. Opt for robust granite or quartz to minimize maintenance with a classic or contemporary look.

Consult a kitchen designer for help deciding between specific colors and patterns. While often a big investment, new countertops can make a world of difference in your home’s beauty and functionality. Take time to weigh all the options before committing to the best material for your needs and lifestyle. With proper planning, you’ll love enjoying your new quartz, granite or marble countertops for years to come.