Granite and quartz are two of the most popular countertop materials on the market today. Many homeowners find themselves trying to decide between these two options when remodeling their kitchens or bathrooms. The major factors that influence this decision are cost, appearance, durability, maintenance, and environmental impact. Analyzing these key factors can help determine whether granite or quartz is the more affordable choice for your next countertop project.
Cost Comparison
The cost of both granite and quartz countertops can vary considerably based on the stone’s quality, thickness, edge treatments, and more. However, looking at price ranges can provide a helpful general comparison.
Granite Countertop Cost
- Low end: $40-$60 per square foot installed
- Mid range: $80-$120 per square foot installed
- High end: $120-$250 per square foot installed
Granite’s wide price range stems from the many stone varieties available. Simple granites with few patterns or veining start on the lower end of the scale. More exotic, rare granites with distinctive markings fall on the high end.
Quartz Countertop Cost
- Low end: $80-$100 per square foot installed
- Mid range: $100-$140 per square foot installed
- High end: $140-$200 per square foot installed
Quartz has a narrower price range because it is an engineered product. The base material is consistent, while aesthetics are varied with added colors and patterns. Higher-end quartz may incorporate more detailed designs.
The average homeowner will likely find granite prices start lower than quartz. Simple, affordable granite types can offer more budget-friendly options compared to quartz’s higher starting costs. However, quartz’s smaller price variances can make it easier to estimate a total project cost.
Appearance
Granite and quartz both come in a diverse array of colors and patterns. However, noticeable differences exist between the two materials’ visual styles.
Granite
With natural granite, no two slabs are exactly the same. Granite forms distinctive speckled patterns and veining in shades of black, gray, red, pink, white, and more. The random markings give each piece a one-of-a-kind look. Some of the most popular granite types include:
- Black granite
- White granite
- Gray granite
- Green granite
Quartz
Engineered quartz offers a more uniform appearance than natural stone. While designs aim to imitate granite and marble, the patterns tend to be more subtle and consistent. Quartz manufacturers create mixes that incorporate specific flecks and veining to achieve each style. Some best-selling quartz color options include:
- White quartz
- Gray quartz
- Black quartz
- Multi-colored quartz
Granite’s bold, unique patterns offer more variation versus the controlled designs of quartz. Homeowners who want countertops that stand out as one-of-a-kind will likely prefer natural granite. Those wanting a more uniform look may opt for quartz.
Durability
Durability and stain resistance are top priorities for kitchen countertops that see daily use. Both granite and quartz earn high marks in these categories, but some differences affect their longevity.
Granite Durability
As an incredibly hard, dense natural stone, granite stands up well to heavy use. However, its durability comes with some vulnerabilities:
- Minor cracking or chipping if subjected to sudden impacts or drops
- Acidic liquids like wine or fruit juice can stain or etch granite surfaces without prompt cleaning
- Sealing required every 1-2 years to prevent staining
Quartz Durability
Quartz has game-changing strength thanks to its engineered construction. Grounds quartz crystals make up over 90% of the material and are fused with resin and pigments. Key durability perks include:
- Flexural strength makes quartz very resistant to cracking or chipping
- Non-porous to prevent staining from spills and liquids
- Does not require regular sealing
Quartz’s augmented properties give it an edge for the highest stain and damage resistance. Granite remains very durable for a natural stone, but quartz’s composition creates enhanced durability.
Maintenance
Caring for and cleaning countertops factors into long-term costs. Granite and quartz have some differing maintenance needs.
Granite Maintenance
Optimal granite care requires:
- Sealing every 1-2 years with a stone sealer
- Immediate cleaning of spills, especially from acidic substances
- Avoiding abrasive cleaners that can damage the surface
- Routine cleaning with a stone-safe soap and water
Quartz Maintenance
Simple, routine care is ideal for quartz:
- No sealing required
- Wipe up spills as soon as possible
- Clean with soap and water or a quartz-safe cleaner
- Avoid abrasive pads and products containing acids or alkali
Quartz’s less demanding maintenance makes it the lower-hassle option. Granite requires more frequent sealing and attention to spills to stay looking its best.
Environmental Impact
Eco-conscious homeowners may consider each material’s environmental pros and cons.
Granite
- Made from entirely natural stone
- Non-toxic and inert once installed
- Mining and transportation use energy resources
- Reusable and recyclable
Quartz
- Some brands use recycled materials
- Resin binders introduce manmade components
- Lower energy use for manufacturing versus mining
- Not recyclable or reusable
If sustainability is a priority, granite’s natural composition gives it an advantage. Though some quartz incorporates recycled content, granite’s lifecycle as a natural stone makes it more environmentally friendly overall.
Granite vs. Quartz: Which is Cheaper Overall?
When weighing all factors, quartz usually comes out as the more affordable option in the long run. The higher upfront cost is offset by lower maintenance demands and exceptional durability. Homeowners who want granite’s distinctive styling still get good value, but will spend more on sealing and maintenance.
Quartz’s cost-efficiency edge may shift in cases where:
- Budget allows selection of lower-priced granite
- Homeowner strongly prefers granite’s natural aesthetic
- Eco-impact considerations make granite a priority
Making an informed choice by prioritizing your needs will ensure you select the right material at the best value. With their gorgeous good looks and longevity, both granite and quartz make smart investments to add style and function to kitchens for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper granite or quartz?
Quartz usually comes out as the cheaper option overall due to its lower maintenance costs and exceptional durability. Granite can be less expensive upfront depending on the type of stone selected.
Is quartz worth the extra cost over granite?
For most homeowners, quartz is worth the extra upfront investment over granite. Over time, quartz’s stain resistance, lack of required sealing, and long lifespan offset the initial price difference.
Why quartz countertops are better than granite?
Quartz is better than granite in terms of durability, stain resistance, and maintenance. Its engineered composition makes quartz almost indestructible and negates the need for regular sealing. Granite remains a durable natural stone, but requires more care.
Is granite going out of style?
Granite remains highly popular and does not appear to be going out of style anytime soon. As a natural material available in a diverse array of unique patterns, granite offers timeless appeal. Many homeowners are drawn to granite for its distinctive styling.
Does quartz add value to home?
Yes, quartz countertops can add value to a home. Quartz’s sophisticated appearance, durability, and low-maintenance reputation make it appealing to potential home buyers. Upgrading older countertops to sleek new quartz can help boost a home’s resale value.
Conclusion
When comparing two of today’s leading countertop materials, quartz regularly beats out granite in terms of cost-effectiveness. However, natural granite remains a stunning, high-end material loved for its one-of-a-kind beauty. Assessing your budget, lifestyle needs, and design goals will help determine if resilient quartz or regal granite is the ideal – and most affordable – choice for your space. With proper care, either material makes an excellent investment that enhances kitchens and bathrooms with long-lasting luxury and convenience.