Quartz and solid surface countertops are two popular options for kitchen and bathroom remodeling projects. Though they share some similarities, there are key differences between these two materials. Understanding the pros and cons of each can help homeowners choose the best countertop for their needs.
An Introduction to Quartz Countertops
Quartz countertops, sometimes referred to as engineered stone, have become increasingly popular over the past decade. They are made from ground natural quartz crystals combined with polyester resins and pigments. The end result is a durable, non-porous material that resists stains, scratches, and heat.
Some key advantages of quartz countertops include:
- Highly durable and long-lasting
- Resists stains, scratches, heat, and moisture
- Easy to clean and maintain
- Available in a wide variety of colors and patterns
- Does not require sealing
Quartz does have a few disadvantages to consider:
- Higher cost than some alternatives
- Can be damaged by excessive heat
- Limited number of thick edge profile options
- Requires professional installation
Overall, quartz combines the beauty of natural stone with excellent durability and low maintenance. The material is ideal for busy kitchens and bathrooms that need to stand up to daily wear and tear.
What Are Solid Surface Countertops?
Solid surface countertops are made from a blend of synthetic resins and mineral fillers. Popular brands of solid surface materials include Corian, Avonite, and Gibraltar. The material is cast into sheets which can be cut and joined to create a seamless countertop surface.
Benefits of solid surface countertops include:
- Seamless, non-porous surface
- Highly durable and scratch-resistant
- Easy to clean and maintain
- Can be repaired and renewed
- Large variety of colors and patterns
- Can be molded into integrated sinks
Potential downsides of solid surface materials:
- Prone to damage from heat
- Can stain from highly pigmented liquids
- Higher cost than laminate options
- Requires professional fabrication and installation
Solid surface provides the look and feel of natural stone, but with more flexibility in design. The seamless installation and wide range of colors make it a popular choice for contemporary kitchen and bath design.
Key Differences Between Quartz and Solid Surface Countertops
While quartz and solid surface share some traits, there are a few notable differences homeowners should consider:
Composition
- Quartz contains ground natural stone while solid surface is entirely synthetic.
Appearance
- Quartz often mimics the look of natural stone with visible patterns. Solid surface has a more uniform, smooth appearance.
Durability
- Both materials are highly durable, but quartz rates slightly higher for scratch, stain, and heat resistance.
Maintenance
- Quartz requires very little maintenance beyond cleaning. Solid surface must be resealed every 3-5 years.
Cost
- Quartz is generally more expensive, starting around $80 per square foot installed. Solid surface runs $70-100 per square foot installed.
Edges
- Quartz has limited edge profile options. Solid surface edges can be customized.
Repairs
- Quartz is difficult to repair seams or damage. Solid surface can be sanded and renewed.
Which is Better – Quartz or Solid Surface?
There is no definitive “better” option between quartz and solid surface countertops. The right choice comes down to your priorities:
Quartz is best if you want:
- Maximum durability and scratch resistance
- Lower maintenance
- Mimicry of natural stone
- Resistance to heat damage
Solid surface is ideal if you prefer:
- Completely custom edges and seams
- Ease of repairing damage
- Contemporary, uniform appearance
- Integrated sinks
Taking lifestyle, design, and budget into account will help guide you toward quartz or solid surface. Consult with an experienced kitchen designer if you are unsure which material is better suited for your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions About Quartz and Solid Surface Countertops
Is quartz more durable than solid surface?
Quartz is generally regarded as slightly more durable than solid surface overall. It has excellent resistance to scratches, stains, impact, and heat. However, solid surface still performs very well and is ideal for busy kitchens.
Can you repair quartz or solid surface countertops?
Minor damage to solid surface can be sanded and repolished. Seams and edges can also be altered. Repair options are very limited with quartz as it is difficult to restore.
Which material costs more, quartz or solid surface?
Quartz countertops tend to range from $80-150 per square foot installed. Solid surface runs $70-100 per square foot installed. Quartz is generally more expensive but prices can overlap.
Does quartz or solid surface feel more like real stone?
With its visible natural patterns, quartz closely resembles stone. Solid surface has a more uniform, smooth appearance that clearly looks man-made to the touch. Quartz delivers a more authentic stone-like feel.
Can you have integrated sinks with quartz?
While solid surface allows for seamless integrated sinks, quartz cannot be molded like this. Quartz sinks require a seam where the sink meets the countertop.
Which type of countertop is best for the kitchen?
For kitchens, quartz is often preferred as it offers superior durability, heat resistance, and a stone-like look. However, solid surface is still an excellent option if you prefer its appearance and customization.
Conclusion
While quartz countertops and solid surface share some qualities, key differences in composition, appearance, performance, and cost set them apart. Quartz offers exceptional durability and a natural look. Solid surface provides a smooth, contemporary look with customization options. Taking into account your needs, preferences and budget will help determine if durable quartz or customizable solid surface is the right selection for your next kitchen or bath remodeling project. Consult with experienced design professionals to ensure you choose the optimal material to suit your home and lifestyle.