Quartz and granite are two of the most popular choices for kitchen and bathroom countertops. Many homeowners wonder which one is more affordable. Here is an in-depth look at the cost differences between quartz and granite countertops.
Introduction
When selecting a new countertop material, cost is often a primary factor. Granite has traditionally been the premium countertop choice, prized for its natural beauty and durability. Quartz countertops provide an attractive, low-maintenance alternative that has surged in popularity over the past decade.
Understanding the cost breakdown of each material can help homeowners decide which fits better within their kitchen remodeling budget. Key considerations include:
- Initial material and installation costs
- Maintenance over time
- Resale value
While granite and quartz are comparable in many ways, the final price tag can vary quite a bit. We’ll explore the key cost differences between these two beautiful countertop materials.
Material Costs
The main driver of total countertop cost is the material itself. Both quartz and granite are priced per square foot, based on the particular style and color you choose.
Granite pricing typically ranges from $40 to $100 per square foot installed. More exotic granite varieties can cost up to $200 per square foot.
Quartz countertops run $55 to $100 per square foot installed. Premium quartz can reach upwards of $140 per square foot.
On the low end, basic granite and quartz are similarly priced. Higher-quality quartz competes squarely with mid-range and premium granite options. Quartz often costs a bit less than exotic granite varieties.
Other Cost Factors
Material cost is only part of the total project price. Other expenses include:
- Fabrication and installation – $40 to $100 per hour for labor. Granite is harder and requires more cuts, potentially adding cost.
- Countertop edges – Decorative edges like ogee, bevel, or Euro cost extra. Granite has more edge options.
- Backsplash – Typically 3-6 inches tall. Tile or matching solid surface adds $10-30 per square foot.
- Sink/faucet – Undermount sinks cost more for installation. New faucets average $200-500 each.
- Demolition and disposal – Approximately $50-150 per existing countertop removed.
Generally, these additional costs are quite similar between granite and quartz installations. The material itself makes the biggest difference in total project pricing.
Maintenance Costs
Over a 10-15 year lifespan, maintenance costs are negligible for quartz. Annual sealing ($1-2 per square foot) is recommended for granite. Re-polishing granite can cost around $150 per hour every few years.
Quartz rarely needs resealing or polishing, giving it a maintenance advantage. But for a typical kitchen, these costs would amount to $100-200 over 5 years – not a huge expense.
Resale Value
Both granite and quartz are premium countertop materials that can add value when selling your home. However, real estate data indicates granite counters may recoup slightly more money – around 50-70% at resale vs. 40-60% for quartz.
This reflects granite’s position as a traditional luxury material, whereas quartz is still gaining widespread market adoption. In the long run, experts expect quartz’s resale value to rise as it becomes more commonplace in higher-end homes.
Quartz vs Granite: Cost Comparison
Here is a summary of average overall costs for quartz vs granite countertops:
- Basic Quartz: $60 per sq. ft. installed
- Mid-Range Quartz: $80 per sq. ft. installed
- Premium Quartz: $100 per sq. ft. installed
- Basic Granite: $70 per sq. ft. installed
- Mid-Range Granite: $90 per sq. ft. installed
- Premium Granite: $120 per sq. ft. installed
At the lower end, quartz often costs $10-20 less per square foot. The gap narrows for mid-grade materials and higher. Premium granite remains pricier than high-end quartz options.
Of course, costs vary by region and precise stone selection. Be sure to obtain local quotes for the specific slabs you are considering.
Should I Choose Quartz or Granite for Cost?
If pinching pennies is a priority,quartz frequently offers savings compared to granite. However, cost differences in the $10-30 per square foot range for an average kitchen may not make a huge impact, especially on a full remodel budget.
Focus on which material best fits your overall kitchen design vision in terms of color, pattern, and style. If you desire exotic granite with intricate movement, the added cost may be worthwhile. For a streamlined, low-maintenance look, quartz costs a touch less in most cases.
Whichever you select, both granite and quartz offer durability and a luxe vibe that boost home value for decades to come. By understanding the cost breakdown, you can decide which stone fits your budget with confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is quartz cheaper than granite overall?
In most cases, yes. Basic quartz starts around $60 per square foot installed compared to $70 for granite. The gap narrows at higher price points, but quartz remains a few dollars cheaper per square foot on average.
Why is quartz cheaper than granite?
Quartz is an engineered stone made of around 90% ground quartz mixed with polymer resins and pigments. It is manufactured in factories under quality control conditions, leading to excellent consistency and less waste. Granite’s complex natural patterns require greater hand-craftsmanship during fabrication. Exotic granites are also relatively rare and costly to quarry.
Is quartz more affordable than granite?
Generally yes, but material cost differences are not always dramatic, averaging $10-30 less per square foot for quartz. Total installed costs depend on the complexity of your kitchen design. Simple layouts favor quartz pricing, while unusual granite shapes may increase the savings.
What is the most affordable countertop material?
Laminate and tile are the most budget-friendly overall options at around $10-25 per square foot installed. But for natural stone, quartz delivers a little more value than granite. Concrete can also be very economical but needs diligent maintenance.
Does quartz add value to a home?
Yes. Both quartz and granite are seen as upscale, luxury materials that boost home resale value. Granite has traditionally been favored, but quartz is quickly gaining favor, especially with younger buyers. Investing in either stone upgrade yields excellent ROI at sale.
Conclusion
When choosing between quartz vs. granite, cost differences of $10-30 per square foot often come down to personal preference rather than budget constraints. Quartz provides slightly more value overall, but both are sound investments that add beauty and function to your kitchen for years to come. Consider the style you love best within your total renovation budget. With either of these high-end materials, you’ll enjoy a kitchen countertop that enhances your home’s comfort and value.