Introduction
Granite and quartz are two of the most popular materials for kitchen and bathroom countertops. Both offer durability and an upscale, stylish look. However, they differ in appearance, maintenance, and cost. So is quartz really more expensive than granite?
The short answer is – it depends. Quartz countertops are generally more expensive than granite per square foot. However, quartz is often seen as a good value since it requires less maintenance and comes in more consistent patterns. When you factor in lifetime costs, quartz and granite pricing is comparable.
Below we’ll explore the key differences between granite and quartz countertops to help you determine which material best fits your space and budget.
Durability and Maintenance
Granite
Granite is an extremely hard natural stone that resists scratches, heat, and stains. However, no stone is impervious. Granite requires periodic sealing to prevent staining and damage over time. Avoiding excessive heat and impacts can also help maintain its durability.
Quartz
As an engineered stone, quartz is even more durable than natural granite. The resin binding makes it non-porous so it never needs to be sealed. Quartz stands up well to impacts, scratches, heat, and stains. Overall, it requires virtually no maintenance.
Appearance
Granite
With natural granite, no two slabs are exactly alike. Granite forms distinct, irregular patterns due to mineral deposits. The unique patterning gives granite counters a one-of-a-kind look. Granite comes in a diverse array of colors from bold reds to neutral grays and tans.
Quartz
Since quartz counters are engineered, the coloring and patterns are very uniform. The speckled look tends to be more subtle. Quartz offers a wide spectrum of colors and styles too, but the overall aesthetic tends to be more uniform.
Cost Differences
Granite
Granite countertops range from $40-$100 per square foot installed. More exotic granites with rare mineral deposits tend to fall at the higher end. Overall, granite pricing depends on the slab quality, color, and precise installation requirements.
Quartz
Quartz countertops run $70-$120 per square foot installed. The exact price depends on the brand, style, and retailer. As an engineered product, quartz pricing per square foot tends to be a bit more consistent than natural stone.
So while granite can potentially be cheaper, quartz consistently falls on the more expensive end of the spectrum. The extra cost of quartz often buys lower maintenance needs and greater consistency.
Factors Impacting Overall Costs
Granite
With granite, the installation costs can vary greatly depending on the complexity of the project. Irregularly shaped granite slabs result in higher labor and wastage costs. Most granite requires professional sealing every 1-2 years, adding to long term costs.
Quartz
Quartz offers more predictable installation costs since the prefabricated slabs are uniform. The non-porous material never needs professional sealing. These factors lead to lower lifetime maintenance costs.
Bottom Line
When calculating total invested costs over 10 or 15 years, granite and quartz often end up costing about the same. Quartz may cost more upfront but saves money down the road through easier installation and zero sealing needs.
How to Choose Between Quartz and Granite
Now that you know the key differences in cost, maintenance and appearance, here are a few factors to consider when choosing between granite vs quartz:
- If you like natural stone with unique veining, go with granite. If uniform speckles suit your style better, quartz is likely the better fit.
- Consider your color preferences too. Want a bright red or bold black countertop? Granite offers more dramatic shades. Prefer a light neutral or white countertop? Quartz excels here.
- Quartz works better in high traffic spaces that will see daily use. Its durability makes it ideal for busy kitchens.
- If you don’t want to seal counters and can afford the higher initial price, quartz is the lower maintenance option.
- Granite can be an exceptionally good value for more basic color patterns installed in simple layouts.
- Both materials add value and elegance to kitchens and baths. It comes down to your design taste and budget.
No matter which material you select for your home, always be sure to buy from a reputable retailer and have an experienced contractor do the installation. With proper purchase and installation, both granite and quartz can serve you well for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is quartz countertop more expensive than granite?
Yes, quartz countertops are generally more expensive than granite. On average, expect to pay $70-120 per square foot installed for quartz and $40-100 per square foot installed for granite.
Why is quartz more expensive than granite?
Quartz is more costly because it’s an engineered product made from natural stone minerals and polymer resins. This meticulous manufacturing process results in a higher price point. The consistent patterns and colors also minimize installation labor and waste, adding value.
Is quartz worth the extra cost over granite?
Quartz can be worth the extra initial investment because it never needs sealing, is extremely durable, and has more predictable installation costs. When factoring in long term maintenance, granite and quartz pricing is very comparable.
Does quartz add more value to a home than granite?
Quartz and granite add about the same value. Both are seen as upscale materials that will make kitchen and bath remodels more appealing to potential home buyers. Neither material clearly outperforms the other in terms of resale value.
Which is better for resale – quartz or granite?
Quartz and granite are equal in terms of resale value. Granite is appreciated for its natural beauty, while quartz is favored for its low maintenance. Both communicate quality and luxury. When selling, cater to buyer preferences by choosing the material that best matches your home’s style.
Conclusion
While quartz countertops come at a higher starting price, their durability, low maintenance, and resistance to damage help offset the initial investment over time. Cost differences between quartz and granite narrow when you factor in long term care and consistent quartz pricing.
Evaluate your budget, kitchen traffic, and style preferences when deciding between these two premier countertop materials. While quartz counters are an investment, many homeowners find their beauty and hassle-free upkeep worthwhile. Carefully weigh the pros and cons of each material before making a decision.