Granite and quartz are two of the most popular countertop materials used in kitchens and bathrooms today. Many homeowners find themselves trying to decide between these two options when remodeling. One of the biggest factors in making this decision often comes down to cost. But is granite actually more expensive than quartz?
An Overview of Granite Countertops
Granite countertops have long been a staple in luxury homes. Made from natural stone, granite is an extremely durable and heat-resistant material that can last for decades. No two granite slabs are the same, with each piece of stone displaying its own unique colors, patterns, and veining.
Pros of Granite:
- Extremely durable and scratch-resistant
- Available in a wide variety of natural colors and patterns
- Resistant to heat, stains, and bacteria
- Can last 50 years or more with proper care
- Adds high-end look to any kitchen
Cons of Granite:
- Expensive compared to other countertop materials
- Requires periodic sealing to prevent stains
- Some porous granites can stain more easily
- Natural stone can crack or chip if subjected to heavy impact
Granite remains one of the most premium countertop materials on the market, commanding a price point to match its luxurious reputation. The material itself is only available through specialty stone suppliers. Most granite countertops are fabricated and installed by professional contractors due to the weight and complexity involved. This also adds to the total installed cost.
Overview of Quartz Countertops
Quartz countertops have surged in popularity over the last decade as an alternative to natural stone. Made from ground quartz crystals blended with resins and pigments, quartz offers the look of granite without some of the drawbacks. The end result is a manmade material that is low-maintenance, consistent in color and pattern, and able to be mass-produced.
Pros of Quartz:
- More affordable than natural stone countertops
- Extremely durable and scratch-resistant
- Resists stains, heat, and bacteria
- Consistent colors and patterns
- Minimal maintenance required
- Can be DIY installed
Cons of Quartz:
- Limited color and style options compared to granite
- Made from manufactured materials
- Seams more visible than granite
- Not heat or impact resistant as natural stone
With its lower cost and hassle-free care, quartz now claims approximately 30% market share of countertop materials and gains popularity each year. The supply chain of engineered quartz makes it more accessible to the average homeowner through big box stores. In some cases, DIY installation is possible.
Cost Comparison Between Granite and Quartz
When it comes to cost, quartz countertops are generally 25-50% cheaper than granite. Here is a breakdown of average installed costs per square foot:
- Granite: $60-$150 installed
- Quartz: $45-$105 installed
However, exact pricing can vary depending on factors like:
- Color and style chosen
- Thickness of the slabs
- Complexity of the project
- Local supply and demand
- Professional vs DIY installation
Unique granite patterns or colors can drive cost per square foot over $200, while basic quartz colors from big box stores can be under $50. The average kitchen uses 30-40 SF of countertop space. Based on that, a full kitchen granite install would be $2,000 to $6,000. The same quartz kitchen would range from $1,500 to $4,000.
Additional costs to consider:
- Transportation of heavy granite slabs
- Professional fabrication and installation
- Demolition and disposal of old countertops
- Any repairs or modifications needed to cabinetry
Is the Extra Cost of Granite Worth It?
For many homeowners, the natural beauty and cachet of granite still justifies the higher initial price point. Keep in mind that a granite counter should last a lifetime if properly cared for, while a quartz counter may need replacing in 15-25 years. Granite also offers unique patterns not found in manmade materials.
However, for budget-minded renovators, quartz provides an extremely durable and low maintenance surface at a more affordable cost. The variety of colors and styles available means quartz counters can complement nearly any kitchen or bath design aesthetic.
Neither material is inherently better than the other—it comes down to personal preference and budget. Keep in mind that professional installation is recommended to ensure proper functionality and fit. Be sure to inspect samples of each material before making a final decision. And consider factors like usage, cooking habits, and overall design to pick the right counter for your space.
FAQs About Granite vs. Quartz Countertops
Is granite better than quartz?
This depends on your priorities. Granite is more heat, scratch, and stain resistant due to its natural composition. It also provides unique natural patterns. But quartz requires less maintenance and is more budget-friendly.
Is quartz healthier than granite?
Both materials are non-porous and do not harbor bacteria growth when properly sealed. Neither has health advantages over the other.
Which material is better for busy kitchens?
Granite is able to withstand heavy usage better than quartz. Very active cooks may benefit from granite’s superior durability and heat resistance.
Can you damage quartz countertops?
Quartz is very durable but not indestructible. Dropping heavy objects on quartz can potentially chip or crack the surface. Overexposure to heat can also damage engineered quartz.
Does quartz stain like granite?
When sealed properly, granite and quartz are both resistant to stains. However, some porous granites are more prone to absorbing liquids if not sealed regularly.
Conclusion
While granite countertops come with a higher price tag, many homeowners feel the natural beauty and longevity make it a worthwhile investment. Quartz provides a more affordable alternative with a remarkable durability and consistency. There is no universally superior option—the right choice comes down to budget, kitchen usage, and personal preference. Carefully examining product samples and professional installation quotes allows homeowners to make the most informed decision for their unique needs. With proper care, both granite and quartz can provide decades of functionality and beauty in the kitchen.