Granite and quartz are two of the most popular choices for kitchen countertops. Many homeowners wonder which material is more expensive – granite or quartz? The answer depends on several factors.
Durability and Maintenance
Granite is generally more durable than quartz. As a natural stone, granite is incredibly hard and scratch resistant. It can last for decades with proper care. Quartz is an engineered stone made from crushed quartz and resins. It is also very durable but not quite as indestructible as granite.
Both materials are relatively low maintenance. Granite should be sealed once a year to prevent stains. Quartz requires no sealing, but occasional cleaning with a stone cleaner. Over time, granite may need professional honing and polishing, while quartz requires less upkeep. The maintenance costs for granite tend to be slightly higher.
Material Cost
The material cost for granite and quartz is fairly comparable, ranging from $40-$100 per square foot installed. Here are some factors that impact the costs:
Granite
- Stone Type: Rare granites like black galaxy are more expensive than common types like uba tuba.
- Color Variation: Granite with dramatic veining and patterns costs more.
- Finish: Honed or leathered granite is pricier than polished.
- Thickness: 3 cm slabs are the thickest and most expensive option.
- Edge Styles: Decorative ogee or chamfered edges add cost.
Quartz
- Brand: Premium designers like Caesarstone are pricier than standard brands.
- Patterns: Quartz with realistic looking veining or patterns costs more.
- Thickness: Thicker 3 cm slabs command higher prices.
- Edge Treatments: Mitered edges and other special treatments add cost.
Installation Cost
In addition to material, installation labor impacts the overall price. In general, installation costs are higher for granite. The process involves meticulous cutting, polishing, and seaming together slabs. The weight of granite also requires extra manpower.
Quartz countertops are lighter and easier to fabricate and install. However, very large quartz slabs can be challenging to maneuver and may require two installers. On average, installation costs around $40-$70 per linear foot for granite and $30-$50 per foot for quartz.
Is Granite More Expensive Overall?
When all factors are considered, granite countertops are generally 20-30% more expensive than quartz. Here’s a breakdown of average overall costs:
- Granite Countertops
- Material Cost: $50-$100 per square foot
- Installation Cost: $40-$70 per linear foot
- Total Cost: $80-$150 per square foot installed
- Quartz Countertops
- Material Cost: $40-$80 per square foot
- Installation Cost: $30-$50 per linear foot
- Total Cost: $65-$120 per square foot installed
However, the pricing can vary dramatically based on your specific choice of materials, designs, and fabricators. It’s best to get quotes for both granite and quartz countertops before deciding.
Pros and Cons of Granite vs Quartz
Here’s a quick comparison of some pros and cons:
Granite
Pros:
- Greater durability and scratch resistance
- Distinct natural beauty with depth and patterns
- Large variety of colors and finishes
Cons:
- Requires yearly sealing
- Can stain if not properly sealed
- Needs occasional professional honing/polishing
- Higher installation cost
Quartz
Pros:
- No sealing required
- Resists stains and scratches
- Easy installation and fabrication
- Consistent patterns and colors
Cons:
- Not as strong as natural granite
- Limited color and style options
- Repairs and replacements difficult
Conclusion
While granite countertops tend to have a higher overall installed price, many homeowners gravitate towards the unmatched beauty and longevity of natural granite. Quartz provides an easy-care alternative at a slightly lower cost. Carefully examine samples of each material and get contractor quotes before deciding if the added cost of granite fits your budget and lifestyle. Your particular kitchen design may warrant splurging on granite or opting for affordable quartz.
FAQ About Granite vs Quartz Countertops
Is granite cheaper than quartz?
Generally no, granite is often 20-30% more expensive than quartz when you factor in both material and installation costs. However, granite pricing can vary dramatically based on the type and color. Some granites may be cost competitive with mid-range quartz.
How much more expensive is granite than quartz?
On average, granite costs $80-$150 per square foot installed compared to $65-$120 per square foot for quartz. However, you need to evaluate specific quotes for your project to determine the exact cost difference. Unique granite and quartz choices could shift the prices in either direction.
Why is quartz cheaper than granite?
Quartz is an engineered product made in factories which reduces costs compared to natural granite that is mined and cut. Quartz is also easier to fabricate and install due to its lighter weight and consistency, bringing down labor costs.
Is quartz worth the cost savings over granite?
It depends on your priorities. For some buyers, quartz is the ideal low maintenance surface worth the compromise on granite’s unparalleled beauty. Other buyers view granite’s added cost as a worthwhile long-term investment in their home. Analyze the pros, cons and costs carefully.
Is white quartz cheaper than granite?
White quartz like Caesarstone is often cheaper than popular white granites like white ice. However, you’ll need to compare quotes for specific materials. A high end designer quartz may be pricier than an inexpensive white granite.
Does quartz add value like granite?
Both granite and quartz are premium countertop materials that can add value to a home. However, granite is generally viewed as a higher-end material that may provide a higher return on investment. Much depends on the particular quartz or granite selected.
Final Thoughts
Granite and quartz both make excellent choices for kitchen countertops. While granite typically comes with a higher initial price tag, many homeowners feel the natural beauty, longevity, and resale value justify the added cost. Quartz provides an easy-care alternative at a more budget-friendly price point. Carefully weigh the pros, cons and costs of each material for your specific kitchen before deciding. With upfront planning, you can end up with gorgeous countertops within your budget – whether you select granite, quartz, or another beautiful material.