Granite and quartz are two of the most popular choices for kitchen countertops. Many homeowners debate which material is more affordable. Here is an in-depth comparison of granite vs. quartz countertops on cost.
durability of each material
Granite is a natural stone that comes directly from quarries, so no two slabs are exactly alike. The mineral composition makes it extremely strong and durable. Granite can last for decades with proper care and maintenance.
Quartz is an engineered stone made from ground quartz crystals mixed with resins and pigments. It is also highly durable but more consistent in pattern and color than natural granite. Both materials are very resistant to scratches, heat, and stains.
Cost Factors
Several factors determine the cost of granite and quartz countertops:
Material Cost
The price per square foot for materials is:
- Granite: $40-$100
- Quartz: $70-$150
Quartz slabs tend to be more expensive than granite. The resin binding process makes quartz more costly to manufacture.
Color and Style
Rare granite colors like blues, greens, and vibrant patterns are premium. More common black, brown, and white granites are budget-friendly.
With quartz, the color and pattern consistency require no sourcing. Simple whites and grays are affordable. Unique quartz styles with bold veining and colors are pricier.
Fabrication
Fabrication is the shaping and finishing of the slabs into countertops. Simple countertop layouts take less time than complex designs.
- Basic cut-out for a sink: $100
- Multiple seams, edges, and backsplashes: $150+
Granite requires more fabrication due to inconsistencies. Quartz has uniform sizing and cuts more predictably.
Installation
Typical professional installation fees range $40-$100 per hour. Granite is harder to maneuver into place. Quartz’s lighter weight makes installation simpler.
Bottom Line Cost
In general, quartz runs $80-150 per square foot installed. Granite countertops cost $60-150 per square foot installed.
While material costs may be lower for granite, extra fabrication and installation fees can make the total expense higher than quartz. The simplest granite jobs can be cheaper, but quartz offers more consistency.
Pros and Cons of Cost
Below is a comparison of some pros and cons related to the cost of granite and quartz:
Granite
Pros
- Wider range of prices ($40-$100 per sq ft)
- Relatively affordable basic colors/patterns
- Can find deals on remnant/discount slabs
Cons
- Premium material costs for rare varieties
- Extra fabrication time increases cost
- Heavy weight makes installation more complex
Quartz
Pros
- Consistent pricing across colors/patterns
- No sourcing drives prices down
- Easy fabrication and lightweight installation
Cons
- No discounted remnants
- Simple designs not much cheaper than complex
- Premium engineered product has higher base cost
Factors Affecting Overall Value
Along with cost, assess the overall value the countertop brings to your kitchen:
- Aesthetics – Both offer design versatility from classic to modern styles. Granite provides uniqueness. Quartz offers uniformity.
- Durability – Granite and quartz are very resilient surfaces that can last for many years.
- Maintenance – Quartz requires little maintenance. Granite needs occasional sealing.
- Resale Value – Kitchen updates with granite/quartz countertops are favored by buyers.
While quartz may cost more upfront, its longevity and hassle-free maintenance can justify the investment. Granite can provide style at a more affordable price point.
Is Granite Ultimately Cheaper than Quartz?
There is no universal answer to whether granite or quartz is the cheaper option. It depends on these factors:
- Budget – Granite costs less on the low end, while basic quartz is pricier.
- Kitchen Size – More surface area favors affordable granite.
- Design Complexity – Simple layouts save costs with granite. Intricate patterns add expenses.
- Color Selection – Premium varieties cost more for both materials.
- Regional Labor – Fabrication and installation rates vary.
Generally, granite is cheaper for smaller, simpler kitchens. For larger, heavily used, and complex designs, quartz offers more value long-term. Homeowners should compare quotes for both materials. The right countertop balances cost, visual appeal, and durability needs.
FAQ
Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about the cost of granite vs. quartz:
Is granite cheaper than quartz for kitchen countertops?
Overall, granite can be cheaper than quartz depending on the kitchen design. Simple granite with common colors and patterns usually costs less than a basic quartz countertop. But rare granite varieties and complex installations make it comparable to quartz pricing.
What is the most affordable granite color?
The most affordable granites are blacks, tans, whites, grays, and other common colors. Premium blues, greens, reds, and exotic patterns are more expensive. Homeowners can find discounted pricing on granite remnants.
Is white granite cheaper than quartz?
White granite tends to be more affordable than white quartz. Natural white granite has some grey veining and color variations. White quartz provides pure whiteness uniformly. The engineered quartz manufacturing results in higher prices.
Is granite or quartz better for resale value?
Both granite and quartz countertops boost resale value for kitchen updates. Granite provides a classic, timeless look that buyers enjoy. Quartz offers modern style and low maintenance that buyers also find favorable. Ultimately, they increase home value similarly.
What is the least expensive countertop option?
The least expensive options for kitchen countertops are plastic laminate, ceramic tile, and butcher block. But these don’t offer the durability and resale value of granite or quartz. Homeowners should focus on the long-term value, not just the lowest initial cost.
Conclusion
Granite and quartz each provide durable, stylish countertops. For cost-conscious homeowners, granite can offer quality material for less, especially with smaller and simpler kitchen layouts. Quartz costs more initially but delivers value through consistent quality, easier fabrication/installation, and fuss-free maintenance. Consider cost along with aesthetic preferences and practical kitchen needs to make the best choice. Consult countertop professionals to get project quotes comparing granite and quartz. This ensures you select the right material that fits your budget and achieves your kitchen vision.