Granite and quartz are two of the most popular countertop materials, and many homeowners find themselves trying to decide between them. There are pros and cons to both options, so determining if granite is better than quartz largely comes down to personal preference and lifestyle factors. Here is an in-depth comparison of granite vs. quartz countertops to help you make the right choice for your home.
Durability
When it comes to durability, granite is the clear winner. Granite is an extremely hard natural stone that can withstand decades of heavy use without showing significant signs of wear. Quartz countertops are made from ground quartz particles combined with resins and pigments, making them susceptible to scratches and marks over time.
Granite is virtually indestructible under normal use. It won’t scorch from hot pans, and resists stains, scratches and chips better than quartz. Granite can last a lifetime if properly cared for, while quartz may need to be refinished or replaced after 10-15 years.
Appearance
Quartz offers more options when it comes to colors and patterns. Engineered quartz surfaces come in unlimited styles from solid colors to patterns mimicking granite and other natural stones.
Granite is only found naturally in a limited range of colors and patterns based on mineral deposits. While granite colors can be stunning, quartz provides more flexibility if you have a specific design aesthetic in mind.
The natural beauty of granite creates depth and visual interest that manufactured quartz lacks. No two granite slabs are exactly alike due to the natural variations.
Maintenance
Quartz is practically maintenance-free, while granite requires some periodic sealing and polishing.
Quartz resists stains and water damage without sealants due to its non-porous nature. Granite is naturally porous and requires sealing every 1-2 years to prevent staining. Quartz rarely needs polishing, but granite counters may require professional polishing every 3-5 years depending on use.
However, granite is easier to clean. Simple soap and water is all that is required. Harsh cleaners and chemicals can damage quartz surfaces.
Cost
Quartz is typically more affordable than granite. Basic quartz countertops start around $50 per square foot installed, while granite slabs start around $60 per square foot installed. More exotic granite varieties can cost $100-150 per square foot.
However, granite offers more stone options at lower price points than quartz. Mid-range granite prices rival quartz, and inexpensive granite types like tiles can provide budget options.
Heat Tolerance
Quartz tends to be more heat resistant than granite. Quartz is engineered to withstand normal household temperatures. But prolonged exposure to heat can damage any stone surface.
Granite is durable, but extreme temperature changes can cause cracks and fissures. Using trivets and hot pads is recommended with both countertop materials.
Stain Resistance
Quartz beats out granite when it comes to stain resistance. Engineered quartz is non-porous, making it highly impervious to stains. However, acidic substances like lemon juice and wine can dull the surface over time.
Granite is slightly porous, so oil and acidic liquids may soak in and stain if left for prolonged periods. Sealing granite makes it very stain resistant for daily kitchen use.
Popularity
Granite remains more popular than quartz in most markets, but quartz is gaining ground. Granite has been the leading material for decades, but quartz sales now make up about 15% of the countertop market.
Many homeowners still prefer the prestige and natural beauty of granite. But quartz is becoming trendy for modern and contemporary kitchens.
Is Granite Countertop Better Than Quartz? Key Takeaways:
- Granite is significantly more durable than quartz in the long run
- Quartz offers more color and pattern options compared to natural granite
- Quartz needs virtually no maintenance, while granite requires occasional sealing
- Quartz is more affordable on average than natural granite slabs
- Both materials are resistant to heat and stains, but quartz is slightly better
- Granite remains the most popular, but quartz is a growing countertop trend
Ultimately, granite tends to provide greater durability, beauty, prestige, and design flexibility with proper maintenance. But quartz can be a smart choice for lower maintenance and more budget-friendly installations. Consider how each material fits your lifestyle, budget, and design vision before deciding if granite is the better choice for your home. Consult with a kitchen designer or countertop installation professional for help choosing between these two great options.
Frequently Asked Questions About Granite vs. Quartz Countertops
Is granite or quartz better for kitchen countertops?
Granite is better than quartz for kitchen countertops if your top priorities are natural beauty, prestige, durability, and design flexibility. Quartz requires less maintenance and offers more affordable options but lacks the look and longevity of real stone.
Does quartz stain easier than granite?
Yes, quartz tends to stain easier than properly sealed granite. Granite can develop stains if not sealed regularly, but is highly resistant when a quality sealant is maintained. Quartz is susceptible to stains from acidic substances despite being non-porous.
Is quartz or granite more durable?
Granite is undoubtedly the more durable material. Made from natural stone, granite can last a lifetime with proper care. Quartz is engineered from resins and crushed quartz, so it can develop scratches and marks over a decade or so.
Which is better for resale value, granite or quartz?
Granite countertops tend to provide a better return on investment and higher resale value. Granite is seen as a luxury material and retains its timeless appeal. More buyers prefer the prestige and authenticity of natural granite.
Is quartz cheaper than granite?
On average, yes – quartz starts around $50 per square foot installed, while granite starts around $60 per square foot installed. Exotic granite can cost over $100 per square foot. However, granite has very affordable options under $50 per square foot as well.
Does quartz need to be sealed?
No, quartz does not require any sealing. Its non-porous composition resists moisture damage without sealants. Granite must be sealed every 1-2 years to prevent staining but is more cost effective overall.
Can quartz get stained?
Yes, quartz can become stained, especially by oil and acidic liquids like wine, vinegar and citrus juice. Quartz is stain resistant but not entirely stain proof like granite needs to be sealed.
Conclusion
When choosing between quartz vs. granite countertops, there are viable arguments to be made for both options. Granite is superior in terms of durability, natural visual appeal, and prestige. But quartz offers an easier maintenance experience, more styles, and potential cost savings. Consider how these pros and cons fit your priorities for your kitchen or bath remodel. And consult a design professional to determine if granite or quartz is better suited for your home improvement goals, lifestyle and budget. With either of these top-tier countertop materials, you can achieve an elegant space you’ll enjoy for years to come.